Best Melatonin Supplements
Compare 381+ Melatonin supplements using our data-driven ranking system. We analyze value (cost per unit of active ingredient), potency (strength per serving), and convenience (pills per day) to help you find the best option for your needs.
Top Picks in Melatonin
All Melatonin Products (381)
Swanson
Swanson, Melatonin, Extra Low Dose , 500 mcg, 60 Vegan Caps
Score: 100$0.04/srv
★4.7(1,099)
Life Extension
Life Extension, Melatonin, 500 mcg, 200 Vegetarian Capsules
Score: 100$0.07/srv
★4.8(408)
Carlson
Carlson, Melatonin, Natural Strawberry Lemon, 300 mcg, 30 Tablets
Score: 99$0.34/srv
★4.8(135)
Nature's Way
Nature's Way, Rest & Restore, Melatonin Free, 30 Capsules
Score: 99$0.60/srv
Life Extension
Life Extension, Melatonin, 300 mcg, 100 Vegetarian Capsules
Score: 99$0.07/srv
★4.7(1,012)
Life Extension
Life Extension, Enhanced Sleep without Melatonin, 30 Vegetarian Capsules
Score: 98$0.73/srv
★4.4(329)
Micro Ingredients
Micro Ingredients, Melatonin, Strawberry, 20 mg, 400 Tablets
Score: 98$0.04/srv
★4.6(152)
Nutricost
Nutricost, Melatonin , 20 mg, 240 Capsules
Score: 97$0.06/srv
★4.7(824)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, High Dose Melatonin, Natural Berry, 60 mg, 60 Fast Dissolve Tablets
Score: 97$0.42/srv
★4.6(8)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, Melatonin, B6 & L-Theanine, Natural Berry, 120 Fast Dissolve Tablets
Score: 97$0.12/srv
★4.6(7)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, Melatonin, Natural Berry, 20 mg, 365 Fast Dissolve Tablets
Score: 97$0.07/srv
★4.7(285)
Nutricost
Nutricost, Melatonin, 12 mg, 240 Tablets
Score: 96$0.05/srv
★4.6(272)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, Melatonin, Natural Berry, 20 mg, 120 Fast Dissolve Tablets
Score: 96$0.07/srv
★4.7(285)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, Melatonin Gummies, Natural Strawberry, 30 mg, 60 Gummies
Score: 96$0.25/srv
★4.7(250)
21st Century
21st Century, Melatonin, Max Strength, Cherry, 12 mg, 120 Tablets
Score: 95$0.06/srv
★4.7(16)
Superior Source
Superior Source, Melatonin, 25 mg, 60 MicroLingual® Instant Dissolve Tablets
Score: 94$0.30/srv
★4.5(368)
NaturesPlus
NaturesPlus, Melatonin, 20 mg, 90 Tablets
Score: 94$0.21/srv
★4.7(1,197)
Vitamatic
Vitamatic, Liquid Melatonin, Natural Berry, 20 mg, 2 fl oz (59 ml)
Score: 94$0.11/srv
★4.6(131)
NOW Foods
NOW Foods, Maximum Strength Melatonin, 20 mg, 90 Veg Capsules
Score: 94$0.17/srv
★4.8(1,243)
Havasu Nutrition
Havasu Nutrition, Night Time Fat Burner + Melatonin, 60 Capsules
Score: 94$0.38/srv
★4.5(253)
Showing 20 of 381 products